Spooky season is here, and who better to celebrate than Art the Clown, the unforgettable horror icon from Damien Leone's Terrifier 2. Whatever! Makes You Happy has reimagined the infamous slasher with an exclusive collection of plush bag charms that are equal parts creepy and cute. Each design features an original in-house illustration, transforming Art into an irresistibly collectible plush while staying true to the mischievous personality that horror fans have come to love. Who says you can't be scary cute?
These Mystery Box Plush Bag Charms are all about the premium details. From the beautifully embroidered facial expressions to the satin-trimmed ruffle collar and sculpted felt accessories like Art's signature sunflower glasses, every piece is crafted to feel special. Clip one onto your backpack, purse, tote, or keys for the perfect horror-inspired accessory. Each Mystery Box contains one randomly assorted plush bag charm, making every unboxing a surprise. Because these are blind-box collectibles, you cannot choose which design you receive, and Mystery Box purchases cannot be returned.
DETAILS:
SHIPPING
Updated July 4, 2026
In stock orders ship within 1-2 business days. If there is any delay on shipping, you'll be notified through email immediately.
Email with tracking number will be sent out once item is shipped. If your package is lost or damaged please contact us so we can help you file a claim through the shipping company.
Your entire order will be shipped out all at once. If some items on your order are not in stock, we will hold off shipping until your entire order becomes in stock. For fastest delivery, please make separate orders.
We want to make sure your order gets to you safely and efficiently!
Please keep in mind that the shipping carrier or service selected at checkout may not always be the carrier or service we ultimately use. Our checkout system calculates shipping primarily based on the weight of your items, but it does not always account for the size of the box or the number of boxes needed for larger or multiple-item orders.
Because of this, the shipping amount shown at checkout may occasionally be different from the actual cost of shipping your order.
For orders with multiple items or larger packages, we may choose a different carrier or shipping service based on the best available rate, package size, weight, and delivery options. This allows us to keep shipping costs as reasonable as possible while making sure your order is shipped safely.
In short: the carrier or service selected at checkout is not guaranteed. We appreciate your understanding as we choose the best shipping option for your order!
If you have a specific shipping request or need a particular carrier, please contact us before placing your order and we'll be happy to see what we can do.
Estimated Delivery Timeframes:
Store Pick-Up:
We offer free store pick up for online orders. Select this option at checkout for your shipping method. We hold orders for up to 90 days. Once the 90 days has passed, your order will be canceled and refunded as store credit. Contact us if you need more time to pick up your order.
Free Shipping Promotion:
RETURNS & EXCHANGES POLICY
In-Store Purchases
All in-store sales are final. We do not offer returns, exchanges, or refunds on in-store purchases.
Online Orders
Online orders may be returned within 7 days of delivery. All approved returns will be issued as store credit only — no cash or card refunds will be provided. Return shipping will be deducted from the store credit.
How to Initiate a Return
If you experienced any issues with your item or order, please contact us so we can better assist you. Our team will review your request and guide you through the return process.
Thank you for shopping with Grotto Treasures — we appreciate your support!
I’m a fan of Terrifier so when I found out about these blind box boxes I immediately had to get my hands on a few! So glad that The Grotto Treasures had them in stock. The store is such a neat and fun store with a variety of new release items and other collectibles.