Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm
Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm

Whatever Makes You Happy! Otonagai The Cryptids Series 2 Mystery Box Plush Bag Charm


  • Low stock - 11 items left
  • Backordered, shipping soon
Regular price$20.00
/
Shipping calculated at checkout.

The adventure continues with The Cryptids Series 2, the next chapter in Otonagai's collectible plush universe featuring an all-new lineup of legendary creatures from folklore and urban legends around the world. Each Mystery Box contains one adorable plush bag charm featuring a super-soft plush body, a signature molded silicone face, a woven hanging tab, and a metal carabiner ready to accompany you on every adventure. Meet Braxie the Flatwoods Monster, Hogan the Hodag (Northwoods Mischief Beast), Fritter the Fresno Nightcrawler, Lulu the Cthulhu, Poppet the Pope Lick Monster,and Nessa the Loch Ness Monster as they continue the mission of helping young cryptids discover friendship, purpose, and a place where they truly belong. Keep your eyes open—you might even uncover the special Color Variant Chase Cryptid hidden within the assortment!

Every Cryptid has a story to tell—and a club to lead. Each new Series 2 character belongs to a unique foundation or society dedicated to welcoming cryptids who feel different and helping them find confidence, community, and acceptance. Inside every Mystery Box you'll discover your plush bag charm, a character information pamphlet filled with lore and personality, an exclusive Cryptid Club membership sticker, and a collectible 1.25" button to proudly display your allegiance. Clip your favorite cryptid onto your backpack, tote, purse, or keys and continue building your Cryptids collection one mystery at a time. The only question is: Which Cryptid Club will choose you?

Product Details

  • Approximate Size: 5.5" H
  • Materials: Plush, Silicone Face, Woven Tab, Metal Carabiner
  • Includes: 
    • 1 Mystery Plush Bag Charm
    • 1 Character Information Pamphlet
    • 1 Membership Sticker
    • 1 Collectible 1.25" Button 
  • Please Note: These items are sold in blind packaging. Character selection is random and specific characters cannot be requested. Opened items cannot be returned or exchanged. All sales are final.
  • Imported

SHIPPING

Updated July 4, 2026

In stock orders ship within 1-2 business days. If there is any delay on shipping, you'll be notified through email immediately.

Email with tracking number will be sent out once item is shipped. If your package is lost or damaged please contact us so we can help you file a claim through the shipping company.

Your entire order will be shipped out all at once. If some items on your order are not in stock, we will hold off shipping until your entire order becomes in stock. For fastest delivery, please make separate orders.

Shipping Carrier & Service

We want to make sure your order gets to you safely and efficiently!

Please keep in mind that the shipping carrier or service selected at checkout may not always be the carrier or service we ultimately use. Our checkout system calculates shipping primarily based on the weight of your items, but it does not always account for the size of the box or the number of boxes needed for larger or multiple-item orders.

Because of this, the shipping amount shown at checkout may occasionally be different from the actual cost of shipping your order.

For orders with multiple items or larger packages, we may choose a different carrier or shipping service based on the best available rate, package size, weight, and delivery options. This allows us to keep shipping costs as reasonable as possible while making sure your order is shipped safely.

In short: the carrier or service selected at checkout is not guaranteed. We appreciate your understanding as we choose the best shipping option for your order!

If you have a specific shipping request or need a particular carrier, please contact us before placing your order and we'll be happy to see what we can do.

Estimated Delivery Timeframes:

  • In-Stock Items: Ships within 1-2 business days. Domestic delivery typically within 3-7 business days after shipment.
  • Pre-Order Items: Ships on or after the estimated arrival (ETA) date listed on the product page. Delivery timeframes begin once the item ships.
  • International Orders: Shipped via DHL, UPS, or USPS. Delivery times vary by destination; customs processing may add additional time.

Store Pick-Up:

We offer free store pick up for online orders. Select this option at checkout for your shipping method. We hold orders for up to 90 days. Once the 90 days has passed, your order will be canceled and refunded as store credit. Contact us if you need more time to pick up your order.

Free Shipping Promotion:

  • Free domestic shipping on orders over $100.
  • Free shipping cannot be combined with discounts codes, rewards, affiliate codes, or promotional sales.
  • Free shipping is automatically applied at checkout if your order qualifies.

RETURNS & EXCHANGES POLICY

In-Store Purchases

All in-store sales are final. We do not offer returns, exchanges, or refunds on in-store purchases.

Online Orders

Online orders may be returned within 7 days of delivery. All approved returns will be issued as store credit only — no cash or card refunds will be provided. Return shipping will be deducted from the store credit.

How to Initiate a Return

If you experienced any issues with your item or order, please contact us so we can better assist you. Our team will review your request and guide you through the return process.

Thank you for shopping with Grotto Treasures — we appreciate your support!

This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.


Recently viewed